|
|
The cruelest cuts Hard work to tender age Franc Ordo'6nez and Ames Alexander Writers of The Charlotte Observer Many old and present workers in three plants of House of Raeford say that he is frequent to see minor workers in the lines of production. Photo/John D. Simmons - jsimmons@charlotteobserver.com
Four months after turning 15 years, Gayton Star began to at night work in the turn in a plant processor of chickens of House of Raeford Farms. Beginning to the 11:00 p.m. every night, when most of the young people of their age were slept, the timid adolescent of black eyes worked in turns of 10 hours in the plant of Greenville, handling filoso knife, cutting muscles of thousands of chickens. “It was scared to cut to me and to remove a finger”, said to me to the Observer. “I really cut some times”. Star lost its work the month last in the cast of immigration greater than sometimes outside carried out in the Carolinas. It was one of the six minor workers, among 15 and 16 years, found between the 331 lengthy workers. Of Raeford is frequent to see minor workers in the lines of production of House, and not only in Greenville. Than 20 more old and present workers in three plants of House of Raeford - in Greenville, West Columbia, Carolina of the South, and Raeford, Carolina of the North said to the Observer that the bird-raising company frequently contract to minor workers. Six present and ex- supervisors said that the managers allowed these hirings to find cheap and docile manpower. Due to the dangers, the federal and state labor laws prohibit that somebody minor of 18 years works in a line of processing of birds. The ex- supervisor Eric Lawson said that after the company initiated the plant in West Columbia the last year, a director of the factory said to him: “Most (of the workers) is illegal or minor. Therefore they will not question anything”. Lawson was forced to leave its work in April, after discussing with its supervisors, according to him. In the series of news articles of February on the conditions of work in the bird-raising industry, the Observer disclosed that House of Raeford had been mentioned 130 times by violations of security in the work place, from the 2000 - between the majors that any other American bird-raising company. The company, cradle in Raeford, are one of the producing majors of chicken and turkey at national level with approximately 6.000 employees and eight plants of processing in the Carolinas and Luisiana. Followed of the cast of the last month, the Department of the Work initiated an investigation on possible violations of infantile work. Miguel Pascal, who obtained to a work in the plant of House of Raeford in West Columbia when she was 15 years old described, it like a hazardous environment, but a place easy to find a job. “Nobody asked whichever years to me had”, said. In a written answer Friday, House of Raeford said that it is following the law. Each applicant must present/display an identification demonstrating that she is 18 years old or more. The company said that it is required that they accept documents that seem to be legitimate and is prohibited to ask for additional documentation. “Lamentably, the documentation presented/displayed by the employees not always is genuine, or exact, even if it seems that it is it”, it said the company. “Also, as we know, everybody does not say the truth all along”. Star arrives at the United States The father of Star did not want that she came to the United States. At least not before he turned 18 years. When it called it to Star of the house of his mother in Oaxaca, Mexico several months before realizing the trip through desert, Tranquilino Gayton remembers to him to have said that it did not allow him to come. Already it lived in Greenville and periodically it sent money to house. “You are too young”, said. “The trip is dangerous. It remains in the school. You must study”. But Star was determined to accompany its older sister, who already had received the permission of the father. She knew of the financial problems of the family. Her mother sometimes cried when there were sufficient money for the food or no medicines. Star wanted to help. Star and its father became angry by three weeks. It even threatened mudar another city if his father did not receive it in Greenville. “I thought at least… will be with me”, said Gayton. “Good! ”, he remembers to have said. “You can come”. Star traveled soon from Mexico to the United States and to Greenville with the aid of a human smuggler at the beginning of the 2007. Hundreds of immigrants have taken a similar way to work in the plants of House of Raeford. The company has had the reputation to be a place where the undocumented people can obtain employment easily, said many workers. When Star visited the plant of Greenville, nevertheless, a woman behind the writing-desk said to him that he was too young. The employee made a pause and soon she made a proposal, said Star to him. “If it pays 300 dollars”, Star remembers the words of the woman, “I can change its date of birth”. House of Raeford did not respond on this specific incident, but it said that he is illegal and it against goes the policy of the company to ask or to require that an applicant pays to be engaged. The company said that it has dismissed employees of human resources that were shortages selling uses. “If it (Star) presented/displayed false documentation, then it has broken the law, as well as the policy of the company”, said the company. “We have audited our registries of I-9 (forms of use elegibility) and do not have certainty of which no employee who has presented/displayed documentation having taught that he or it was less than 18 years old at the time of his hiring, work in the company has occurred him. Adolescent in the line Star, sitting in the sofa of its room, as soon as it pretends his age. With his supported legs, it turns his hair moored in a horse tail while it speaks of his friendly in Mexico. While most of their old classmates practiced sports, they coqueteaban to the boys, and they attended dances, Star took care of turns of all night in a factory of concrete cold, helping to turn thousands of birds into you cut advisable for restaurants, stores and cafeterias. “I do not dance much here”, said. Star, now of 16 years, worked in a plant, well-known like, Columbia Farms during approximately 18 months, first cutting muscles and soon moving under the line to cut wings. To work in a plant of chickens is hard, dirty work. The workers remain shoulder to shoulder, doing less than 20.000 you do not cut in turn. With a knife in its hand right, Star cut the chickens as fast as it could. The meat seemed to fly.

To work in a plant of chickens is hard. The workers remain shoulder to shoulder, doing less than 20.000 you do not cut in turn. Photo/John D. Simmons - jsimmons@charlotteobserver.com
The women majors on the line of processing of the plant of House of Raeford Farms did not have major problem, but Star had difficulties by its adolescent muscles. “The others maintained the rate because they were great”, she said. “More difficult Era for me. I am small”. The companions who tried to help Star said that its age was not any secret. Anita Baptist worked in front of Star. It and Star sometimes interchanged sites when the adolescent remained back. “She is only one girl”, said Baptist. “A chamaca”. After its turn, Star took off pieces of fat of chicken of its clothes. Its skin seemed to absorb the scent of the meat. Their trembling hands would burn to him during hours. Weeks after losing his work, it says that some fingers still hurt to him. It rises and takes hold the bottle of an analgesic hot lotion of a shelf near the kitchen. “My father”, says, “every night rubbed my hands with this cream”. Habitual practice Old and present workers say that Greenville was not the unique place where House of Raeford engaged minor workers. Dozens of minors, say, also they obtained employments in West Columbia and Raeford. Fernando Arevalo, whom he supervised to approximately 80 workers in the plant of West Columbia, until outside dismissed to October, he said that he knew of five or six minor workers. They seemed and acted like young people, often speaking of the way in which they do it to the adolescents, said. Arevalo sometimes asked their ages. “They said to me directly. “I am 15 years old””, said. Another supervisor still employed in the plant, said that the company is conscious of the minor workers, it ignores but it due to the necessity to maintain in movement the lines of production. “When I have said that somebody seems too young, they have said to me that she does not make any question”, the supervisor said, who asked that their identity is protected because still works for the company. “They say “you you must assume that the papers are real””. Lizzie Mae Harris, that worked as supervisora in the Raeford plant by many years before leaving in the 2003, considered that approximately two dozens of workers in their department were minor. The boys still did not shave themselves, he said, and lacked the force to do the work designed for mature men, like throwing the skin of the turkeys. “One could see them”, said she, “and knowledge who were babies”.

Lizzie Mae Harris, that worked as supervisora in the Raeford plant by many years, says that the minor workers lacked the force to do the work designed for mature men, like throwing the skin of the turkeys. Photo/John D. Simmons - jsimmons@charlotteobserver.com
Miguel Pascal said that nobody asked its age to him when he began to work in the plant of West Columbia. He was 15 years old when they gave a knife him to pit they put and it to work in the line of production the past year. His father says that often he dreams whereupon his older son had remained in the school and would have continued until becoming a doctor or lawyer. But, he says, when you come from a poor family of mountains of Guatemala that is rarely an option. “When one is poor”, his father said, “must accept options that one would prefer not to have them”. He assures that it is very common in Guatemala that somebody of 15 years works. Miguel and his father said that many Americans do not understand the daily fights of many Guatemalan families. Before they came to the United States, the family not only passed work to buy food. Also to pay by the fertilizer to be able to work simple basic foods, like maize. But many think that the children are not done for such work. Marcille Chavis, that clerk of production in the plant of House worked as of Raeford in Rose Hill, during approximately 20 years, before leaving it in the 2003, said that it can remember to have seen about 50 workers of the plant, who she suspected were minor. When it pressed to one of the young people who worked in the line of processing on their age, he admitted that he was 15 years old, said. All he worried that it. “Good part of the time they were not sufficiently mature to know what to do in case of emergencia”, assured. House of Raeford said that the supervisors who know that an employee is minor, must report it to the department of human resources because it is a violation of policy of the company and the federal law. “Any manager of the company that allows the use of minor workers or illegal, in the same way would be violating the policy of the company and would be dismissed”, said the company. “And, in fact, we have dismissed employees only by such reasons”. Star said that the cast of the 7 of October was one of the most frightful moments of its young life. Several federal agents entered the plant of right Greenville before the 9:00 a.m. He migrates “It”, shouted the workers. Star said that she and others tried to escape by an emergency door. This did not move. It said that it called to his sister by his cellular telephone, crying, to say goodbye to him. It was taken to an empty factory to approximately 10 minutes of the plant. They took the fingerprints him and was interrogated. Star said that it begged to the agents. It said on his father and his sister to them in Greenville. Star was released under safekeeping of its sister. They said to him that it would be contacted by federal authorities. She still can be deportee. “I am not wanted to go”, said she. “I want to help mother. I have only done a little. I want to do more”. Ordo'6nez franc: 704-358-6180
The state and federal laws specify the age in which the young people can do certain works. Some dispositions keys are:
Work nonagriculturist: • The smaller young people of 18 years cannot most of carry out works considered risky by the federal laws - including uses in empacadoras of meat, carpenters and techadoras. He does not allow himself minors of 18 years to handle many electrical tools. • To the 16 years of age, the young people can work in any use nondesignated like risky by the federal or state laws. • To the 14 years of age, the children can work retail in certain sales, and expendio of foods and gasoline. • He allows himself the minors to take care of children, to give newspapers or to work like actors to any age.
Limits of working hours: • The minors cannot work during hours of school. • To the 14 and 15 years of age they cannot work more than three hours in day of school, or more than 18 hours in one week of school. They cannot either work more than eight hours in a day that do not have school, or more than 40 hours in one week without classes. In addition, he will not allow himself them to work before the 7:00 a.m. or after the 7:00 p.m., except in the summer, when they can work until the 9:00 p.m.
Agricultural work: • The minors of 16 years of age will not be able to carry out works considered risky according to federal laws. Between the prohibited uses they are: use of electrical machinery of farm or to work in scaffolds or stairs of more than 20 feet in the air. • To the 14 years of age, the minors can carry out any agricultural work not considered risky. • Children of 12 and 13 years of age, that work in the same farm that its parents, can carry out nonrisky agricultural works. • Smaller children de12 years can work in small farms as long as to his they approve it parents. • The infantile labor laws do not apply in children who work in farms of property or handled by their relatives. Limitations during hours: • The children cannot work during hours of school.
Source: Department of the Work
The cruelest cuts Minors in the work field happen unnoticed You love Alexander and Franco Ordo'6nez Writers of The Charlotte Observer
Nery Chestnut grove entered a work that was not own for a boy of its age. Behind schedule of the last autumn, this native one of Guatemala of 17 years controlled a machine fiber-removing machine of wood panels damaged to turn them into a type of sawdust used in gardening. When a fellow worker in the plant of Greensboro returned to carry out another task, he did not see Nery - he found until it within the fiber-removing machine. “A person would not have to die thus”, said Luis, the older brother. “… Wine with a dream and found the death”. Decades after the promulgation of designed regulations to prevent tragedies like this one, thousands of American young people still are wounded in uses considered like uncertain for young workers. During a typical day, more than 400 youthful workers they are wounded in the work. In average, every 10 days a young worker dies. The fulfillment of the law is handicapped, in spite of new tests that many employers do not make labor case foreseen by the law infantile. The investigations done by the Department of the American Work, are handicapped in a 46% from fiscal year 2000. “There are many minors who are being solicitd to do works that are prohibited for them - and have been prohibited because they are dangerous”, Carol Runyan said, that handles the Hurt Research center of Prevention of of the University of Carolina of the North. “… Our system is failing to them”. More than 3 million smaller young people of 18 years they are used. The regulations prohibit most of that these minors realize a variety of risky uses, including the works related to the processing of meat. The last month, in a cast of immigration realized in the plant of House of Raeford in Greenville, Carolina of the South, six minors was between the lengthy workers. Three working young people said to the Observer that they less than had 18 years of age when they obtained to use in the plants of House of Raeford, requiring that they realize thousands of you cut to the day with sharpened knives. The company says that it asks to those who inhales a use, that presents/displays an identification that indicates its age, but all the documentation is not exact. In Agriprocessors, a great plant of processing of meat in Postville, Iowa, the authorities recently blamed the proprietors of thousands of violations by infantile work, after to find that they asked for adolescent employees who used you close circular, that cleaned floors with powerful chemical substances and carried out other dangerous tasks. “The casts in Postville and Greenville show that young of 15 and 16 years they do some of the most dangerous works in the country”, comments Reid Maki of National Liga of Consumers…. “It is hour that the Department of American Work investigates bird-raising plants and slaughter houses”. A study in workers of the construction of 16 and 17 years of age in Carolina of the North, published in 2006, found that more of the 80 percent they made tasks that clearly were prohibited. A national survey of working young people in the areas of sales retail and services, published in 2007, found that more than half of men and more of the 40 percent of women they carried out prohibited tasks. Runyan, that is Co-author of both studies, says that most of the fault falls in the employers. “I suspect that there are employers who simply do not do case to him to the law”, she said. “And I suspect that there is others do not have nor idea”.
Little to dissuade the employers The employers who often disobey the laws of infantile work confront few consequences. The federal law stipulates a maximum pain of 11.000 dollars by each violation, but in the 2006 pain average it was less than 1.000 dollars, according to National Liga of Consumers. Total the federal penalties by violations of infantile work, decayed in a 29 percent from the 2000 to the 2007. Federal laws of infantile work cover great employers, as well as to small companies dedicated to the commerce between states. The majority of the states also has their own laws of infantile work, that generally small employers cover and impose additional restrictions. But the state penalties tend to be smaller. According to the law of Carolina of the North, the maximum fine by each violation is 250 dollars. In cases where the employers fail in making sure that their young workers obtain youthful certificates of use, the maximum pain is 50 dollars by each violation. “It does not seem to be sufficiently dissuasive”, it says to the director of wages and schedules of Carolina of the North Jim Taylor, whose office is responsible to make fulfill - but not to write the infantile labor laws of the state. In Carolina of the South, the maximum pain by violation is 1.000 dollars by person, by work. The civil servants of the Federal Department of the Work say that they have made much to help to improve the conditions of the young workers. Alexander Passantino, administrator of the division of wages and schedules of the Department of Work of the country, said to a committee of the Congress in September that the civil servants have worked to reinforce laws of infantile work, to rise brings back to consciousness citizen and to focus in industries where it is more probable that young workers are dead or wounded. The number of young people died in the work is handicapped during the last decade, emphasized. But the critics say that the government has made little progress. From the 2001, the hurt numbers of between young workers have practically remained equal, according to the National Institute for the Health and Occupational Security. In the hearing recently realized in the Congress, they asked witnesses if the regulators are doing sufficient to protect the minors. Several said that the answer was no. “Much more it can and it must be made to protect better to our young people of the risks and dangers that face in the work place”, Sally Greenberg declares, executive director of National Liga of Consumers. The dangers of the bird-raising industry The plants of processing of meat are between the work places where better protections are needed, say the defenders of juniors. In bird-raising plants, the workers are surrounded by dangerous machines and chemical substances. And often he demands himself to them that they do every day thousands of you cut with filosos knives, work that can leave them with laceraciones and debilitated nerves and muscular problems like the syndrome of carpiano tunnel. But the Observer found that the young people find a job in these plants. Elena Moon said that it was 16 years old when she went to work in the plant Mountaire Farms in Lumber Bridge, Carolina of the North. At the outset, it said, a civil servant of human resources said to him that it was not sufficiently greater. But when he returned with a recommendation of a cousin who worked in the plant, the civil servant asked to him if she could do the work, said. “It said, I do not want verte in infirmary or they will dismiss”, said Moon to me, now of 20 years of age. In the line of processing, it comments, they gave little training him and worked with a supervisor who often shouted to him so that he hurried. Doing thousands of you cut with knives every day, its hands began to him to hurt. “Sometimes it could not maintain the knife”, said. Moon, that worked under the name of Rosaura, said that often it felt desire to leave, but resisted because it had to pay to members of his family in Mexico, that financed their trip to the United States - and knew that this one was one of the few uses that could obtain. Moon said that other minors also worked in the plant. “I was not the unique one”, said. “… They knew all it”. Mike Tirrell, vice-president of operations of Mountaire Farms, said that Moon signed its papers indicating that it was 18 years old when was contracted in the 2005. She was dismissed approximately 15 months later, after the civil servants of the company discovered that the information of its request was false, according to Tirrell. She said that she could not speak of the specific Moon accusations, but stressed that the scene that it described with the civil servant of human resources, violated the policy of the company. It denied that the company has employed numerous minor workers. “We took each step that reasonably we can take to assure the elegibility the aspirings and workers in our plants, including names and correct directions and ages”, it said.
The last day of Nery Nery Chestnut grove lived a healthy life. It liked to play soccer and it was conducted free of alcohol, cigarettes and fights, it said the brother of Luis. In June of the 2007, it went to work for Pallet Express, a manufacturer in Greensboro with approximately 80 employees. It presented/displayed his identification, that demonstrated that it was 17 years old, affirms its brother. After several months in the work, they asked that it handled the fiber-removing machine to him of wood panels, an enormous machine that turns damaged wood panels into a type of sawdust used in gardening. The day of the accident, the fellow worker of Nery went to look for a fork-lift truck, said Luis. For the moment at which the companion returned, Chestnut grove had been devoured by the fiber-removing machine. OSHA of Carolina of the North mentioned to the company by eight serious violations, including failing in putting required guards of security in the machine. The agency fined to Pallet Express with 12.000 dollars. The department of the work at state level also fined to the company with 250 dollars to put to a junior without a certificate of youthful use in a dangerous work, that he must not have been doing. The family, meanwhile, has presented/displayed a demand alleging, among other things, that the company failed in providing to Nery with the appropriate equipment with security, training and supervision. The vice-president of the Lynn company Bell said that she could not comment on the case because still she is in investigation. Luis vividly remembers to behind schedule see the pale face of his cousin that in October of the 2007. There was an accident, said his cousin. Oyendo the news, Luis sank deeply in a chair. “Not”, it moaned. “Era a boy”, said Luis.
Flexible rules in agriculture The work in agriculture is responsible by more deaths in the place for work between smaller children of 15. Nevertheless, the laws of infantile work are more flexible in agriculture than in any other employer at national level. Children of 12 years - and in some cases until more young people - are allowed to work in the field. Young people of fourteen and fifteen years can handle a great tractor if they take a course from security. Young people of sixteen can do any work agricultural, without mattering how dangerous is. Nevertheless, defenders of security in the work field think that the laws are indulgent, does not follow everybody them. Heather Anderson, defender of working young people of the field, describes to have seen young of up to six years working in a field of blueberries near Whiteville, Carolina of the North, a day of past June when the temperature reached the 95 and 98 degrees. Anderson, that works with the Association of Programs and Opportunities for Workers of the Field, said that it visited a dozen of farms in the area during his trip of two weeks and “every day we saw children”. In some of the days, it said, the temperature exceeded the 100 degrees. The National Institute of Health and Occupational Security has pushed to fit the federal rules to protect better the children in agricultural works, but until the present, no action has been taken as a result of its recommendations. Critics also assure that the regulators have made very little to investigate and to penalize those that violate the rules. In the 2006, just 2% of the investigations done by the Department of the Work were in agriculture, in agreement with National Liga of Consumers. The number of investigations of infantile work in the agricultural sector has lowered of 142 in 1999 to 28 in the 2006. Federal officials say that to enforce the law it is not his unique tool. They say that they have tried to protect working young people of the field, by means of the creation of announcements public and development of other materials to educate to the parents and the adolescent ones on security practices.
Deaths in the Carolinas In Carolina of the South, many working young people have died in the work in recent years, in agreement with governmental documents and published reports. Among them: • In May of the 2006, Joshua Daniel Martinez Castle of 16 years, was working for a company of construction in Jedberg when he was above between the metal beams of a ceiling and shut up 20 feet more down finding the death.
• In January 28, 2003, two workers - Rigoberto Xaca Sandoval of 15 years and its brother Moser Xaca Sandoval of 16 - died in Blythewood, when the trench of eight feet where they were installing electrical conductors collapsed.
• In March 9, 2004, a worker of construction of 16 years, died when falling of a scaffold of 10 feet of height to a plate of concrete.
The News feels very proud of to have comprised of this excellent series “the cruelest cuts”, written by reporters of The Charlotte Observer, when having the opportunity to translate some of articles to the Spanish and to as much present/display them to our readers in www.newsonlinefind.com as in the printed edition of the News. The translation was made by the publisher Diego Barahona and director Hilda Gurdián. The graphical design was in charge of the designers Malena Benton and Mario I castrate.
|